Showing posts with label living wage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label living wage. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

How do people get by on less than a living wage?

Yesterday I provided some living wage figures for the DMV.  In MOCO, a single adult needs to make at least $13.20 an hour to make a living wage.  A single parent with one child needs to earn $25.02.  I concluded yesterday's post by noting that discussions about a living wage are so important because a lot many people don't make one. So, how do people get by when they DON'T make a living wage.

Let's look at what people do to get by in terms of housing.  I focus on housing here because as the author's of the living wage calculator note, housing (and childcare costs) tend to be higher in metropolitan areas. 

In densely populated parts of the DMV (e.g. downtown Silver Spring, Columbia Heights, Ballston), people with low wages often double and triple up in one bedroom apartments.  This happens in 2 bedrooms too, but not as often.  Why?  Well, for starters, there just aren't as many 2- and 3-bedrooms in the DMV as there are 1-bedrooms.  And, their scarcity makes them more desirable, and thus more expensive.   

In my last apartment in DC there were two families who lived in 1-bedroom apartments in my building.  One family included 2 parents and 1 child.  The other had 2 parents and 2 children.  I don't know what their wages were, but I do know that squeezing into a 1-bedroom apartment was what they had to do to afford to live in our neighborhood in the city.  Even the small houses in the area cost upwards of $800,000.  I understood why they were willing to make the squeeze.  The schools were good and access to buses downtown was literally out our front door.  But, it was a sacrifice too.  A 1-bedroom with 3 and 4 occupants is definitely cozy, but exceptionally crowded.  There's too little closet space, not enough privacy, and only one toilet for the all of you.   

Millennials do this teaming up as well.  Although many of the millennials flocking to DC are young professionals, it is useful to keep in mind that being young and professional doesn't mean you can afford DC's luxury rents (Numbeo puts the average 1 bedroom rent in the city center at $1,984.38).  This is especially the case for interns and entry level staffers on the hill, and almost anyone at any level working for an NGO.  There's a reason a lot of millennials haven't left the nest, or have returned to it.  They can't afford to rent.

People do this in the suburbs as well.  There, though, the house is what gets piled up with people.  In households where people don't make a living wage, it is not uncommon for multiple generations of families live together under one roof.  Sometimes, families will also rent out their basements, or even single rooms.  Housing costs in DC's suburbs are lower than in the city, but they are still high, especially when compared to suburban locations in smaller cities, or in cities that aren't experiencing urban booms (e.g. Cleveland or Detroit). 

For people who don't make a living wage, the idea of a nuclear family in a single family house is just that--an idea. It isn't a reality, or likely to be one anytime soon. 




 

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

What's a 'living wage' in Montgomery County? the DMV?

Although there are hundreds of definitions out there for a living wage, they are all variations on a simple theme.  A living wage is supposed cover the basic cost of living (housing, healthcare, daycare, food, etc.).  

The DMV is an expensive place to live (see my earlier blog post about how much it cost to buy a house in the DMV).  But, how much do you need to make to cover the basics here?  My gut says 'a lot', but my gut isn't good at math. Fortunately, MIT has a handy living wage calculator.  Let's take a look for the DMV shall we?

A couple of caveats.  First, a good benchmark for thinking about these wages is to consider the federal minimum wage--currently at $7.25 an hour.  Second, the calculations from the site are also conservative.  That is, the actual or real living wage may be higher in some places.  The site's authors' note, for example, that the calculator "is likely to underestimate costs such as housing and child care" in metropolitan areas (i.e. the DMV).  Finally, it is useful to keep in mind that a living wage is NOT a middle class wage.  This is the wage you need to get by on.  It only covers the basics--specifically: food, child care, medical costs, transportation, taxes, and an 'other category' for emergencies.  What's not covered?  Entertainment (going to the movies), vacation (a trip to the beach), savings (for a rainy day), education (tutoring, private school, college for you or the kids).  

So, let's start with a comparison between DC, Maryland, and Virginia.  (the table below is created from data selected from the website, which includes much more detailed data).



Place
Living Wage
Adult

Adult, 1 child
2 Adults, 1 child



Hourly wage
$13.68
$26.37
$23.54
DC

Annual income
$28,454
$54,842
$48,959

Before taxes





Hourly wage
$11.79
$23.41
$21.04
Maryland

Annual income
$24,515
$48,696
$43,757

Before taxes





Hourly wage
$10.54
$20.77
$19.49
Virginia

Annual income
$21,927
$43,200
$40,543

Before taxes





A few patterns emerge.  First, DC has the highest living wage, followed by Maryland and then Virginia.  Second, the living wage is higher for a single parent with one child than it is for 2 parents with 1 child.  Why, you might ask?  Well, single parents usually HAVE to rely on child care.  In 2 parent households childcare costs can be eliminated because one parent can stay home with the child. This doesn't always happen, of course, but it CAN happen. 


Now, let's look at how areas within Maryland stack up against each other.  To capture the state's diversity, I'm including a rural, suburban, and urban place. 



Place
Living Wage
Adult

Adult, 1 child
2 Adults, 1 child



Hourly wage
$7.70
$18.59
$16.21
Garrett Co.

Annual income
$16,013
$38,672
$33,715

Before taxes





Hourly wage
$13.20
$25.02
$22.66
Montgomery

Annual income
$27,464
$52,049
$47,135

Before taxes





Hourly wage
$11.24
$22.88
$20.51
Baltimore

Annual income
$23,373
$47,595
$42,667

Before taxes





Not surprisingly, MOCO is more expensive than rural Garrett County.  But, it is also more expensive than Baltimore (city).  For people who live in the DMV this won't come as a surprise.  Many people commute from Baltimore to DC because it costs less to live there.  In this regard, even though MOCO is a suburb, its proximity to DC is both a blessing (all those free museums) and a curse (high cost of living).

Finally, a couple of points.  MIT wouldn't be coming up with a living wage calculator if most people made one.  We have these kind of nifty tools precisely because many people don't make a living wage--especially in expensive metropolitan areas like the DMV.  Second, the federal minimum wage--$7.25--simply isn't enough to live on anymore, even in rural Garrett County (though it isn't far off).

In  my next post I'll talk about how people get by in a context where they don't make a living wage.  See you soon...